The Odells were prominent figures in the early history of Twinsburg, and their story reflects the growth and development of the community in the 19th century. John Odell and Lydia Cody married in 1831, embarking on a journey that would see them play a pivotal role in the local economy. Just two years after their marriage, in 1833, they settled in Twinsburg, a burgeoning town with great potential.

Upon their arrival, John Odell recognized the need for a general store and promptly built one on the Square’s northwest corner. This store became a central hub for the community, providing essential goods and services to residents in the area. It was a place where neighbors gathered, fostering a sense of community and connection among the townsfolk.

In 1847, the Odells expanded their business by hiring Alonzo Nelson, a former teacher in Twinsburg, to assist in the store’s operations. Nelson brought his experience and dedication to the role, contributing to the store’s success. However, tragedy struck in 1851 when John Odell passed away, leaving Lydia to manage the business. The following year, she decided to sell the store to Nelson, who had become an integral part of the operation.

Unfortunately, fate took another turn when, just two years later, the original store succumbed to a devastating fire, reducing it to ashes. Undeterred, Alonzo Nelson quickly rebuilt; instead of building another wood frame building, he used an early form of concrete blocks to make it fireproof (one of the first buildings of its type built in Ohio). The new store was more extensive and included living quarters on the second floor. This new establishment not only continued the legacy of the Odell family but also became a cornerstone of the community.

The Nelson store, built on the Odell property, served the townsfolk for over a century. It was more than just a store; it was part of Twinsburg’s infrastructure. Mr. Nelson became the Post Master and his building hosted the local Post Office, making it a key point for communication and connectivity in the area. Additionally, it became the home of the Rev. Bissell location of the
Bissell Library that became the Twinsburg Library, serving the community’s educational needs. The store also housed the first telephone switchboard in Twinsburg, marking a significant advancement in local communication.

However, the passage of time brought change, and in 1956, the beloved landmark was razed to make way for the new Richner Hardware Store. The demolition marked the end of an era for the Odell and Nelson legacy in Twinsburg. Nonetheless, the contributions of John and Lydia Odell, as well as Alonzo Nelson, remain a cherished part of the town’s history, symbolizing the
entrepreneurial spirit and community ties that have shaped Twinsburg over the years. Their story is a testament to the resilience and determination.

Twinsburg Trivia reveals intriguing connections to the Odell family, particularly through Lydia Odell’s maiden name, Cody. Lydia had a nephew named William Cody, who was involved in a dramatic incident during a turbulent time in American history. At just eight years old, William was traveling with his father in the Kansas Territory when he was stabbed with a Bowie knife. This occurred while he was making an impromptu speech advocating against slavery at a
trading post—a reflection of the intense conflict and division over slavery in that era.

Fortunately, Isaac Cody, William’s father, survived the attack; however, the incident took a toll on his health. He struggled to recover fully and ultimately succumbed to pneumonia two years later. This tragedy occurred against the backdrop of significant historical changes, as the Kansas Territory officially outlawed slavery in 1860 and became the 34th State the following year.

William Cody would later become Buffalo Bill Cody, a legendary figure of the late 1800s. Buffalo Bill emerged as a multifaceted personality—he was a bison hunter, an Indian fighter, an Army scout, and a showman. His larger-than-life persona captivated audiences across the country, and he became famous for his Wild West shows that celebrated the American frontier and its myths. In 1872, Buffalo Bill was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor for his bravery during the Indian Wars. The metal was rescinded in 1917. Although he was a Civil War veteran, he was a civilian Army scout during his act of heroism. In 1989, his Metal of Honor for bravery was restored by an act of Congress.